(Photo by Megs Harrison on Unsplash)
While predatory journals rarely make the front page of newspapers, there has been no shortage of other stories around in recent week focusing on other examples of predatory behavior. From the conviction for rape of celebrity Russell Brand to allegations against author David Walliams, the word ‘predator’ has been topping the news agenda for several weeks.
In the publishing industry, the continued existence of predatory journals has been well documented, but what about other forms of predatory practices? Sadly, nefarious actors have used research and publishing as vehicles to execute scams against academics and their institutions, and new technology has only served to accelerate the process.
Good to talk?
A new form of predatory practice that has recently been highlighted is that of the predatory podcast. This was exposed by psychology professor and research integrity specialist Neil Martin on his Bluesky account, where he published a dialog he had with a supposed podcast producer, who sought to extort him for a “logistics and post-production” costs of $150.
The scam was likely AI-powered, and echoed similar approaches people have received in varied industries via email, where they are approached with a fantastic-sounding job opportunity and asked to submit an application, only to be told it needs some ‘expert’ work to improve it, whereupon a fee is introduced to complete the work for a few hundred dollars. While the figures here are relatively small, like predatory publishers the actors are operating at scale, with most of the work automated. It only takes a handful of people to be deceived for thousands of dollars to be earned by the con artists.
Proceed with caution
Predatory conferences have long been recognized as another form of fraudulent activity, preying on researchers who need to present at an event, but not offering any peer review or quality checks associated with reputable academic conferences. These events pivoted during Covid, where the inability travel meant that they moved online. Revenues per delegate decreased, but costs plummeted and numbers grew exponentially, making these events much easier to manage.
Lately, the link between conferences and paper mill activity has been made by a number of European authors, who presented their paper at a (legitimate) conference showing that over 1,700 titles harvested from paper mill activities appeared in IEEE conference papers across 280 conferences. These papers were written by 6,500 different authors from 55 different countries and also appeared in other conference proceedings and journal publications.
Helping hands?
There is some good advice online to spot these dodgy operations. Industry expert Lou Peck offered some good advice on the Scholarly Futures blog this summer (here and here), but while academics in some countries may have got wise to the tricks being played on them, others in countries such as China may be more vulnerable.
Sadly, news and advice on tackling the problem are not trustworthy themselves, with technology again at the root of the problem. Tempted by AI to help you identify predatory behavior? We gave ChatGPT the following prompt:
‘Give me a list of the 10 most likely predatory journals using Beall’s List as a primary source‘
In reply, it offered 10 journals which, to be fair, included various caveats about not being ‘ranked’ and need to treat them as having “historical risk flags” and not verified. This was borne out when we compared the list to Cabells’ Predatory Reports database – only five appeared in there as verified predatory journals, one of one had an incorrect URL, and three others cited an incorrect publisher. As with all forms of predatory behaviour, caution and critical thinking are essential at every step of the way.
